As Tyler Blackburn illustrated last week, Pretty Little Liars fans are no joke. But for Ian Harding, who plays Ezra Fitz on the hit show, things are starting to get weird. "There’s a whole Tumblr called ‘Ian’s Tongue,’ or something like that, and it shows all the times that you see my tongue while me and Lucy [Hale, who plays love interest Aria] are going at it.” It doesn’t help that Harding plays a sexy English teacher who falls for his teenage student—a storyline that PLL fangirls, being mostly teens themselves, can’t get enough of. The 26-year-old actor chatted with us over a bowl of chickpeas, opening up about the perils of being a professional heartthrob, Ezra’s sweater vests ("Fucking love ‘em”), and getting Punk’d by Lucy Hale.